To begin the exploration into gender bias in student evaluations, we first explore whether it is true that students evaluate female instructors using different criteria than male instructors. The author does not mention another recent study showing that evals are also genderbiased. Student ratings of teaching play a significant role in career outcomes for higher education instructors. Given the widespread use of student evaluations of teaching for tenure and promotion decisions, it is important to be aware of possible bias in the evaluations. Male students give significantly higher scores to male professors on overall satisfaction and on the teaching dimensions related to delivery style. The bias affects how students rate even putatively objective aspects of teaching, such as how promptly assignments are graded. Student and faculty perceptions of student evaluations of. The present study examined the influence of professor and student characteristics on students preconceptions of college professors. The standards that people apply shift depending on the. Every semester brings with it a new series of articles, blog posts and stories about gender and racial biases in teaching evaluations. Glau, northern arizona university mcmanigell grijalva is an associate professor of english. Student evaluations of teaching mostly do not measure. Hard evidence would be difficult to establish, because part of the point of these evaluations is that the bias is plausibly deniable. These gender biases create different incentives for male and female teachers to change.
Chrisler, and kathryn quina, excerpted from career strategies for women in academe. Men are sexualized when they teach in fields culturally associated with femininity and women are sexualized when they teach in fields culturally associated with masculinity. Agnes g dentremont, university of british columbia, vancouver dr. Numerous studies have examined the possibility of a gender bias in student evaluations of teaching and smallscale studies tend to find very different results from largescale studies. Gender bias in teaching evaluations briq institute.
Women and instructors of color are systematically rated lower in their teaching evaluations than white men, even when there are no actual. Administrators are unlikely to admit that they knowingly employ a biased instrument in employment proceedings. The author does actually mention the view that more effective teaching leads to higher grades and higher student evals. The official student evaluations of facetoface courses.
Mcmanigell grijalva, oklahoma city university greg r. We exploit a quasiexperimental dataset of 19,952 student evaluations of university faculty in a context where students are randomly allocated to female or male instructors. How student evaluations are skewed against women and. This article uses data from a french university to analyze gender biases in student evaluations of teaching sets. Understanding teaching style differences between men and women abstract using data from over 9,000 faculty that participated in the faculty survey of student engagement, this study found gender differences in the percentage of class time spent on various. Professor age and gender affect student perceptions and grades shauna w. Is there gender bias in student evaluations of teaching. Pdf students gender bias in teaching evaluations researchgate.
Huston1 colleges and universities are making uneven progress towards reaching gender and racial equity. This paper provides new evidence on gender bias in teaching evaluations. If this is the case, teachers that apply better teaching methods, which simultaneously re. Reviews a number of laboratory and real life studies and summarizes their. Many universities use student evaluations of teachers sets as part of consideration for tenure, compensation, and other employment decisions. Student perceptions of and expectations for male and female instructors. Gender bias in student evaluations the society pages march 18. For additional wmstl files now available on the web, see the wmstl file list. Course syllabi for a politically charged social science course were constructed with versions varying by teaching style. In this study we examined the effects of professor gender and. The possibility of a race bias is a relatively new area of inquiry, however, as.
Analysis of data from 741 college classes in which there were at least 10 male and 10 female students revealed small gender preferences in student evaluations of teachers, particularly in female students rating female teachers. In a 1985 study, it was found that generally for male students, gender plays. We exploit a quasiexperimental dataset of 19,952 student evaluations of university faculty in a. A large and constantly growing body of academic literature demonstrates how bias shapes these tools. This bias is driven by male students evaluations, is larger for. Wmstl subscriber susan basow later contributed her paper, student ratings of professors are not gender blind. Students gender bias in teaching evaluations 31 organized, better communicators, more interactive, and better at giving quality exams and feedback 2000. Set are biased against female instructors by an amount that is large and statistically significant. Gender and teaching evaluation university of maryland. To motivate students to complete endofcourse evaluations and to provide useful feedback through those evaluations, the vanderbilt center for teaching recommends instructors talk with their students about the importance of course evaluations and how those evaluations are used.
Our contribution is unique in its use of content analysis to examine student. Gender bias in course evaluations and the easiest way to reduce it want fairer course evaluations for female instructors. She researches the rhetoric of culture, ethnicity and. The bonus should be determined by average gender bias in teaching evaluations at their institution or national. The results of fixed effects and generalized ordered logit regression analyses show that male students express a bias in favor of male professors. The goal of this study was to investigate if there is gender bias in student evaluations.
Student evaluations of teaching center for teaching. Results of the content analysis of official evaluations for facetoface courses are in table 1 and the rate my professors content analysis is in table 2. Gender bias in teaching evaluations iza institute of labor. Gender bias in teaching evaluations research repository. Gender biases in student evaluations of teaching women in. Student evaluations of teaching set are widely used in academic personnel decisions as a measure of teaching effectiveness. Hotness affects student evaluations more than gender. Rhetoric, gender and evaluations of teaching regina a. Despite the fact that neither students grades nor selfstudy hours are affected by the instructors gender, we find that women receive. This supports the idea that gender discrimination is behind the di. An annotated bibliography, at the center for research on learning and teaching at the university of michigan. Male students in particular tend to give higher overall satisfaction scores. Teaching style rather than gender may explain these preferences.
Gender bias in student evaluations the percentages of comments that characterized each theme were compared. You can enter any other word or twoword phrase into the box below to see how it is split across gender and discipline. Could faculty course evaluations impede further progress toward parity. Researchers administered a modified version of the teacher evaluation forms to 58 students male30. Professor age and gender affect student perceptions and. Gender biases in student evaluations of teachers anne boring. For instance, if a woman is evaluated poorly by students and a man is evaluated highly, it could be due to gender bias or instructorrelated. Nevertheless, it will be impossible for us to pin down the exact mechanism. Gender bias in student evaluation of teaching among undergraduate. For example, experiments with students in online courses show that identical courses are rated lower if the instructor is. Pdf gender bias in teaching evaluations researchgate.
Female instructors were found to teach in a different style than males, encouraging discussions and lecturing less 2000. Disssin paper series iza institute of labor economics. Although instructor gender has been shown to play an important role in influencing student ratings, the extent and nature of that role remains contested. College students across the country fill out forms at the end of each course they take called student evaluations of teaching set. Exposing gender bias in student ratings of teaching. While difficult to separate gender from teaching practices in person, it is possible to disguise an instructors gender identity online. In this paper, we investigate whether there is a gender bias in university teaching evaluations, i. Student evaluations can take a lot of different forms. Although instructor gender has been shown to play an important. Gender bias in course evaluations and the easiest way to. Growing evidence of antifemale bias in student surveys. Gaubatz 2000 is there gender bias in student evaluations of teaching.
This cleverlydesigned study was able to determine gender bias by having students evaluate online instructors, one male and one female. Employing student evaluations as a measure for teaching quality might be highly misleading, dr wagner added. Gender bias in student evaluations texas tech university. Or, on the other hand, they could also reflect gender differences in teaching style. We exploit a quasiexperimental dataset of 19,952 student evaluations of university faculty. But i think the evidence for concluding that bias is a feature of teaching evaluations is in my favor. Also, the different teaching dimensions that students value in male and female professors tend to match gender stereotypes. However, in doing so, they may be engaging in discriminatory practices against female academics. Her technical research in orthopaedic biomechanics is focused on joint motion and cartilage health with a particular. The second is the statement on student evaluations of teaching from the.
We exploit a quasiexperimental dataset on 19,962 student evaluations of their teachers at maastricht university in the netherlands. Pdf this paper provides new evidence on gender bias in teaching evaluations. Gender bias in teaching evaluations this paper provides new evidence on gender bias in teaching evaluations. Findings indicate students were much less likely to agree that set encourage faculty to grade more leniently, that they have an influence on a faculty members career, or that they lead to changes in courses andor teaching styles. Although previous studies have found evidence of bias against ethnic minority lecturers in student surveys, the erasmus researchers found that any such effects were not statistically significant. Student evaluations provide rich information about teaching performance, but a number of factors beyond teacher effectiveness influence student evaluations. In fact, the authors titled their paper student evaluations of teaching mostly. How student evaluations are skewed against women and minority professors. Explores the potentially damaging effects of gender bias in student evaluations of teaching, specifically with regard to student expectations. Evidence relating to the question of gender bias in teaching evaluation sheila kishler bennett department of sociology, bryn mawr college a total of 253 students enrolled in nonscience introductory courses at a liberal. Questions that are unspecific about what metric the student should use to assess a teaching quality also become hotbeds of bias. Gender biases in student evaluations of teachers abstract this paper uses a unique database from a french university to show that student evaluations of teachers sets su er from gender biases.
Is gender bias an intended feature of teaching evaluations. Agnes dentremont is an instructor in the department of mechanical engineering. For instance, if a woman is evaluated poorly by students and a man is evaluated highly, it could be due to gender bias or instructorrelated attributes, such as teaching style or overall teacher quality. Im here to talk to you today about bias in student evaluations of teaching. New analysis offers more evidence against student evaluations of teaching submitted by colleen flaherty on january 11, 2016 3. One definition of bias is if a teacher or course characteristic affects teacher evaluations, either positively or. Gender and teaching evaluation stephanie riger compiled the following public and private responses to her january 1993 wmstl query about gender bias in teaching evaluation. They also applied the tests to evaluations for four sections of an online course in a randomized, controlled, blind experiment at a u.
320 704 631 304 1430 816 605 1662 824 1391 1331 794 200 343 1213 1171 414 53 314 1641 1341 1536 776 1467 845 91 643 393 1035 177 1306 1064